More Ideas, More Problems: Government Thinking During a Crisis
(English captions & Hindi subtitles available)
(English captions & Hindi subtitles available)
Entrepreneurs and state officials have been transforming Bangalore from a city where the “backend” technology work of the world is sent to a new startup hub known for entrepreneurship and innovation. Since 2012, I have been tracking the multiple sites and practices through which this “startup city” is produced. One key site in developing citizens as entrepreneurs is through a specific focus on developing women as entrepreneurs.
The “haphazard” nature of urban planning in India habitually becomes a topic of public debate whenever our cities encounter a major crisis, like the urban flooding that Chennai witnessed recently. Since urban planning and its enforcement are routinely declared the culprit of India’s “dysfunctional” cities, it is important to examine the roots underpinning India’s current urban planning regime.
As the first wave of the coronavirus pandemic resulted in a near-complete lockdown of the Indian economy, digital platforms were in turmoil amidst raging protests from their workers. Delivery service platforms such as Swiggy faced workers’ agitation against repeated paycuts and scaling down of their monthly incentives at a time when they were forced to deliver in containment zones, risking personal health and braving violence from the police forces on the ground.
The COVID-19 crisis brought the woes of Indian platform workers into sharp focus, as the lack of labor rights—regulated work hours, minimum wages, data rights, and social protection—exacerbated the precarity and insecurity of their work. As the lockdown was implemented in major cities, digital delivery platforms became all-purpose pick-and-drop services in response to surging demand.
This year witnessed a renewed reckoning about the rights and wrongs of partition. Both Palestine and Ireland—partition scenarios most commonly associated with India and Pakistan—have seen debates about the merits of the process of partition and its finality played out with a greater urgency over the past few months. For India, lessons offered from both these locations should be valuable, particularly in the current context of the attempt to politically weaponize Partition memories.
Gilles Verniers is currently a Senior Fellow at the Centre for Policy Research, New Delhi, and Karl Loewenstein Fellow & Visiting Assistant Professor in Political Science at Amherst College. Previously, he was an Assistant Professor of Political Sciences and Co-Director of the Trivedi Centre for Political Data, which he founded, at Ashoka University. He received his Ph.D. in Political Science from Sciences Po Paris in 2016 and has trained in Political Science, International Relations, and Economic and Social Ethics at the universities of St.